In this lifelong critique of mental illness as a myth, szasz simultaneously maintained an interesting counterfactual conditional. My aim in this essay is to raise the question is there such a thing as mental illness. The myth of mental illness 741 szasz s ideas concerning the unconscious, rationality, and responsibility a second major criticism of szasz s work surrounds his supposed lack of clarity around the notion of the unconscious, and his belief that all behavior is intentional and that persons are therefore responsible for it. Thomas szasz wrote over thirty books and several hundred articles, replete with mordant criticism of psychiatry, in both. Oct 31, 2019 thomas szasz, the myth of mental illness. He has consistently sought to apply classical liberal principles such as bodily and. Foundations of a theory of personal conduct first ventured this uncompromising view, its author thomas szasz visited cornell university in upstate new york.
Fifty years after his book the myth of mental illness. Everyone defined as a mental health professional is now legally responsible for preventing his patient from being dangerous to himself or. Szasz argues that mental illness is theory that society uses to explain irregularities in a person. This paper was delivered as a plenary address at the international. The success of epicurus, the failure of thomas szasz. All problems in living are attributed to physicochemical processes which in due time will be discovered by medical research. The notion of mental illness based on the myth of mental illness by thomas szasz. Over that half century szasz has maintained a consistent campaign against the therapeutic. In 1960, thomas szasz published the myth of mental illness, arguing that mental illness was a harmful myth without a demonstrated basis in biological pathology and with the potential to damage. If we accept this definition of disease, then it follows that mental illness is a metaphor asserting that view is stating an analytic truth, not subject to empirical falsification. A critical examination of this concept is therefore. Thomas szasz 19202012 maintained that, unlike true diseases of the brain and body, mental illness is a destructive social construct that medicalizes living and deprives people of their dignity.
Herbert pardes president, american psychiatric association concerning a. He has been repeating and elaborating that message since publication of his iconoclastic book in 1961. Szasz may be criticized for his oversimple analysis of the concept of illness and for his failure to recognize that values are central to all clinical decision. It is the making of good choices in life that others regard, retrospectively, as good mental health. Pdf the notion of mental illness based on the myth of. The myth of mental illness offended many psychiatrists and many mental health patients as well. Thomas szasz is professor of psychiatry emeritus, state university of new york upstate medical university, department of psychiatry, syracuse, new york, usa. The author believes that what is nowadays accepted as mental illness is whatever psychiatrists say it is and that psychiatry has, with increasing zeal, defined more and more kinds of behavior as mental illness. A critical examination of this concept is therefore indispensable for understanding the ideas, institutions, and interventions of psychiatrists. In 1960, thomas szasz published the myth of mental illness, arguing that mental illness was a harmful myth without a demonstrated basis in biological pathology and with the potential to damage current conceptions of human responsibility.
Pdf the myth of thomas szasz jeffrey oliver academia. Szasz launches a blistering attack upon the words and concepts that psychiatrists use. Foundations of a theory of personal conduct that they are merely indirect forms of communication, thomas szasz. One of szaszs basic arguments is that mental illness is a myth. He was professor emeritus of psychiatry at the state university of new york health science center in syracuse, new york.
Foundations of a theory of personal conduct revised edition, i tried to show how and why the concept of mental illness is erroneous and misleading. Sustained adherence to the myth of mental illness allows people to avoid facing this problem, believing that mental health, conceived as the absence of mental illness, automatically in sures the making of right and safe choices in ones conduct of life. He is well known for his books, the myth of mental illness 1960 and the manufacture of madness. Thomas szasz quotes about mental illness az quotes. Since the notion of mental illness is extremely widely used nowadays, inquiry into the ways in. The film centers around a spirited debate between szasz and dr.
It was not a book on psychiatry but a book about psychiatry and many critics overlooked the fact that it was supposed to be a radical effort to recast mental illness from a medical problem into a linguisticrhetorical phenomenon. Revisiting the myth of mental illness and thomas szasz. According to szasz, medication, hospitalization and mandated psychotherapy are little more than coercive, dignityreducing forms of clinical practice. Thomas szasz and the myth of mental illness explores the biography and the philosophy of controversial psychiatrist thomas szasz, in particular paying attention to the legal implications and social consequences of his theories. Only a fool would believe that mental illness is a myth. One of szasz s basic arguments is that mental illness is a myth. My argument was limited to the proposition that mental illness is a myth, whose function it is to disguise and thus render more palatable the bitter pill of moral conflicts in human relations. Oct 17, 2012 it was his first invitation to speak to the groupand his last szasz was not on good terms with the association. Szasz 1960 first published in american psychologist, 15, 1118. Fifty years after the myth of mental illness thomas szasz. In the present work, i shall try to show how and why the ethical convictions and social arrangements. The concept of mental illness is freely used in all the major. Mar 01, 2010 thomas szasz s classic book revolutionized thinking about the nature of the psychiatric profession and the moral implications of its practices.
Just look aroundanguished teenagers, depressed adults, distracted children. Psychiatrist and social critic thomas szasz unsettled the psychiatric establishment in the 1960s, challenging its foundational notions around normalcy, mental illness and treatment. Thomas szasz, crazy talk and the myth of mental illness. Thomas szasz 19202012 was a psychiatrist, psychoanalyst, and author who was well known for his criticisms of the field of psychiatry and the concept of mental illness. Szasz s arguments have provoked considerable controversy over the past five decades. Foundations of a theory of personal conduct szasz, thomas s.
According to szasz, the concept of mental illness is fundamentally flawed because it is based on the premiss that it is caused by nervous system disorders. Thomas szaszs classic book revolutionised thinking throughout the world about the nature of the psychiatric profession and the moral implications of its. Apr 15, 20 the reason for this is that there is no such thing as mental illness. In this article, szaszs analysis of crazy talk is considered in the context of his wider critique of psychiatric theory. The assumption is made that some neurological defect, perhaps a very subtle one, will ultimately be found for all the disorders of think ing an d behavior.
A comparative study of the inquisition and the mental health movement which set out some of the arguments with which he is most associated. View enhanced pdf access article on wiley online library html view. We argue that szasz has performed an important service by drawing attention to psychiatric prejudice regarding the causes of abnormal behaviour, and by pointing to the role of values in psychiatric decision making. Thomas szasz, the myth of mental illness in 1961 thomas szasz published a book entitled the myth of mental illness. This classic publication elevated thomas szasz into a position of international renown and controversy. He saw the uses of diagnostic systems such as the dsm as wrongly implying the presence of actual disease. In 1961 thomas szasz published a book entitled the myth of mental illness. Thomas szasz the myth of mental illness cchr international. Szasz state university of new york, upstate medical center, syracuse m y aim in this essay is to raise the question is there such a thing as mental illness. Psychiatric diagnoses are stigmatizing labels phrased to resemble medical diag. The essays, mental illness is still a myth, and defining disease, thats the argument of thomas szasz, professor emeritus of psychiatry at the state university of new york in syracuse.
It received much publicity, and has become a classic, well known as an argument against the tendency of psychiatrists to label people who are disabled by living as mentally ill. The psychiatrist who didnt believe in mental illness aeon. Correctly speaking, however, these are diseases of the brain, not of the mind. He was highly critical of the socalled medical model for understanding human struggles and difficulties. Foundations of a theory of personal conduct is a 1961 book by the psychiatrist thomas szasz, in which the author criticizes psychiatry and argues against the concept of mental illness. He moved to the united states from hungary when he was a teenager and pursued a degree in physics followed by a. Sustained adherence to the myth of mental illness allows people to avoid facing this problem, believing that mental health, conceived as the absence of mental illness, automatically insures the making of right and safe choices in ones conduct of life. By diagnosing unwanted behavior as mental illness, psychiatrists, szasz argues, absolve individuals of responsibility for their actions and instead blame their alleged illness. Szasz makes a frontal assault on the power of psychiatry, arguing that mental illness is a myth and that the power accorded to psychiatrists to decide if people are legally responsible for their actions, have them committed to hospitals, and prescribe various psychotropic medications is fundamentally misfounded. The myth of mental illness by thomas szasz psychology. There was, for him therefore, no medical, moral, or legal justification for involuntary psychiatric intervention or hospital admission. Thomas szasz, who died at age 92 on september 8, 2012, was the author of the myth of mental illness and dozens more and had long been the scourge of the psychiatric establishment. According to one school of thought, all socalled mental illness is of this type.
It received much publicity, and has become a classic, well known as an argument against the tendency of psychiatrists to label people. Sep 12, 2012 thomas szasz is a psychiatrist and author well known for his criticism of the modern psychiatry movement. Thomas szasz and the myth of mental illness 1989 imdb. In this book, he basically argued that the psychiatric diagnosis of mental illness was a selfserving act of egoaggrandizement and obedience to the system. The myth of mental illness encourages us, more over, to believe in its logical corollary.
Mental illness is a myth, whose function it is to disguise and thus. In logic, a counterfactual conditional is an ifthen statement indicating what would be the case if something were true, although it is not true. Sep 12, 2012 thomas szasz, a psychiatrist whose 1961 book the myth of mental illness questioned the legitimacy of his field and provided the intellectual grounding for generations of critics, patient. Thomas szasz and the myth of mental illness the socjourn. How society uses the term mental illness as an excuse for its imperfections, a theory that is out of date and over used.
State university of new york, upstate medical center, syracuse. Over nearly five decades szasz, an md, argued passionately and knowledgeably against involuntary commitment of the mentally ill, against the war on drugs, against the. In 1961 he had published a book attacking the specialty, the myth of mental illness. This site is like a library, use search box in the widget to get ebook that you want. Thomas szasz, psychiatrist who led movement against his. At the core of virtually all contemporary psychiatric theories and practices lies the concept of mental illness. What is termed mental illness is in fact behavior disapproved of by the speaker. Brendan d kelly, pat bracken, harry cavendish, niall crumlish, seamus macsuibhne, thomas szasz, tim. Revisiting the myth of mental illness szasz claims that many critics misread his book. Thomas szasz s classic book revolutionized thinking about the nature of the psychiatric profession and the moral implications of its practices. Preprint pdf available august 2018 with 437 reads how we measure reads. This is the preface for the new edition of the myth of mental illness.
He was there to speak to an audience of students, many. Foundations of a theory of personal conduct is a 1961 book by the psychiatrist thomas szasz, in which the author criticizes. Nov 15, 2016 an overview of szasz s criticisms of psychiatry. Download the myth of mental illness or read the myth of mental illness online books in pdf, epub and mobi format. Thomas szasz on the myth of mental illness youtube.
612 332 394 140 925 494 1217 276 513 1018 1531 418 1185 1435 967 827 1415 971 1355 511 201 834 471 675 1014 546 1243 1157 1166 1002 511 151 1434 1194 458 147 1438 34 825